Brigadoon Anime Review

Quick Review

• Reviewer: Marc
• Review Date: 2006-08-18 (updated 2006-08-18)
• 2.5 stars out of 5 (?)

Note that this review is only based on the first few episodes of the series.

What is up with this series? About equal parts Figure 17 and Jubei-chan The Ninja Girl, it somehow combines part of the premise of a classic fantasy musical with cartoony characters, random situation comedy, serious action, and a world that at times seems strangely realistic despite all the bizarre stuff going on in it.

Brigadoon is so offbeat that I'm not sure whether I like it or not. Admittedly, after the first episode (which is really chaotic and cartoony) it settles down a bit, but it still keeps up a strange mix of highly caricatured characters and some strikingly realistic situations--bullying at school, the government's reactions to things, and the amazingly detailed images of the Japan of a bygone era. Not quite on the scale of Jubei-chan, but those who've seen that series will know what I'm talking about.

Set in 1969 (don't see that in an alien invasion flick every day), probably one of the most noteworthy things about Brigadoon is its period-piece nature. Unfortunately, a lot of the nostalgic cultural bits won't be appreciated by most non-Japanese viewers, and in other cases the unrealistic nature and nostalgic "culture-lag" of many anime shows makes things that haven't been around in several decades in the real Japan seem a little too familiar. In any case, though, the series lays out an interesting image of a quieter, more traditional Tokyo, and there's a lot of appealing detail in some of the out-of-the-way locales.

[Random side note: in a small slip, a scene of the New York skyline prominently features the World Trade Center, which was less than half finished at the time the show is supposed to take place.]

The look of Brigadoon is, at the very least, distinctive. The character designs are broad, with simple linework (again, reminded me of Jubei-chan), and a few particularly caricatured faces gracing the minor characters. The simplistic cel art is something of a contrast with the realistic backgrounds, which were for the most part detailed and quite well done. In any case, the animation is smooth and well-executed, with plenty of creative and attractive battles (creative in that our heroine has no fighting abilities of her own, but still does her best to help out one way or another).

The voice acting in Japanese is solid, although the characters are, keeping in tune with the rest of the production design, rather broad. On a cursory look the English version appeared a bit stiff, but I'll reserve judgement. The music seems interesting, including a few vaguely celtic tunes that seemed to be a nod to the Scottish setting of this series' namesake.

Since Brigadoon is a long series and has one heckuva strange start, it's hard to say where it's going to go or how worth watching it's going to be on the whole until I've seen the whole thing. So far, the plot seems to have some interesting places to go and a lot of room for fun, but the combination of realistic action and cartoony characters was a little too jarring for my taste.