Maetel Legend Anime Review

Quick Review

• Reviewer: Marc
• Review Date: 2002-06-06 (updated 2011-02-15)
• 1.5 stars out of 5 (?)

Maetel Legend is yet another piece of Leiji Matsumoto's epic space opera universe. A sort of origin story for the ever-mysterious Maetel (along with Emeraldas), it is clearly intended for fans of Galaxy Express and its progeny, and doesn't offer much to non-fans past an uneven, tragic fairy tale. Past unimpressive visuals that look two decades older than they are, the story is halting and jumps around seemingly at random. Individual scenes are good, but it doesn't fit together into a coherent whole.

Maetel Legend is an interesting story about Maetel's past for fans of Galaxy Express 999 and its kin. For those who aren't, the story functions on its own, but it's just too poorly constructed for me to be able to recommend it unless you're very much in the mood for a tragic sci-fi fairy tale.

Read the full-length review...

Full Review

• Reviewer: Marc
• Review Date: 2002-06-06 (updated 2011-02-15)
• 1.5 stars out of 5 (?)

Maetel Legend is yet another piece of Leiji Matsumoto's epic science-fantasy universe. A sort of origin story for the ever-mysterious Maetel (along with Emeraldas), it is clearly intended for fans of Galaxy Express and its progeny. Sadly, it's too choppy and visually unimpressive to offer much to non-fans past an uneven, tragic fairy tale.

I should note that I do not happen to be part of Maetel Legend's target audience. Although I'm familiar with the world, I'm neither a fan nor particularly knowledgeable, and it's definitely designed to appeal to people who are both. People who do qualify will get the detailed backstory of Maetel and Emeraldas with all the melodrama and classic anime style you'd expect. For the rest of us, I'll offer a rundown from the perspective of its merits as a standalone series.

To start with, although there are plenty of tie-ins to things that happen later in the Matsumoto-verse, the story is fairly self-contained. It's also rather inconclusive--it is, after all, an origin story--but there aren't a lot of characters that the viewer needs to know by reputation to appreciate. Unfortunately, knowing them by reputation is the main reason you'd bother watching.

I have two problems with Maetel Legend. One is that I have trouble with Matsumoto-style space fantasy. Don't mistake it for science fiction, or even space opera--the technology and sci- is there, but for the most part the sci-fi trappings just provide a different locale for a classic fairy tale. As you might expect, logic is frequently sacrificed for style or metaphor. As long as you take it for what it is, this shouldn't be a big deal.

A much bigger problem is that the story isn't put together well. It usually moves along briskly, and there are several dramatic peaks, but the drama is broken up by awkward lulls. Several times an abrupt scene change in the middle of what appeared to be buildup toward a climax left me wondering where we were and how we got there. Elsewhere there are rather large plot holes and a couple of scenes that don't make sense when they occur. If you only look at the broad metaphor of the story, or focus on individual scenes (mainly those between the Queen and her daughters), Maetel Legend is interesting and dramatic, but there are big problems with the flow of everything in between.

The visuals share this lack of coherence. Several scenes don't have a particularly good sense of space, and the backgrounds, though not badly painted, are uninspired. Maetel Legend also looks much older than it is, a disappointment in in light of what could have been (and was, in other more recent Matsumoto-verse series like Queen Emeraldas). I don't mind that the character designs and visual style have the classic look of other Matsumoto series. What I mind is the rough art, choppy animation, and weak coloring, all of which are a little too familiar from lower-budget series of the Galaxy Express era. On the positive side, there are a few memorably creepy scenes involving the mechanization process. Musically, the production is surprisingly quiet. What music there is is unremarkable.

The voice acting in Japanese is broad and a bit cheesy, but that mostly fits with the production, and Keiko Han as the Queen has a few solid dramatic scenes. On the other hand, apparently taking a machine body does something weird to your synthetic sinuses, since Hardgear (Takashi Matsuyama) has an appropriately evil but amusingly nasal voice. The dub isn't bad at all, with Dan Green's Hardgear probably being the standout voice. Although I liked Veronica Taylor's slightly harsher take on Emeraldas, Maetel (Lisa Ortiz) apparently inherited Hardgear's perpetual head cold.

In the end, Maetel Legend is an interesting story about Maetel's past for fans of Galaxy Express 999 and its kin. For those who aren't, the story functions on its own, but it's just too poorly constructed for me to be able to recommend it unless you're very much in the mood for a tragic sci-fi fairy tale.

Have something to say about this anime? Join our newly-resurrected forums and speak your mind.

Related Recommendations

Probably not the best of the stories that make up Leiji Matsumoto's universe, but it's still one of them, and an important one at that. The themes of sacrificing one's humanity to technology are handled in many other anime; some include Gunnm, Ghost in the Shell, AD Police Files, and Angel Cop, none of which have anything else thematically in common with Maetel Legend. Better matches are tragic fairy tales or allegories like Windaria or Weathering Continent.