White Radish Perfect Collection Anime Review

Quick Review

• Reviewer: Marc
• Review Date: 2003-06-08 (updated 2012-07-21)
• 2 stars out of 5 (?)

This collection of shorts by White Radish showcases a solid cross-section of fun anime; each captures some classic anime feel, boiling down a few simple plot elements and adding a little satirical twist. The stories are bare bones (cute, scantily-clad girls fighting monsters and young boys battling evil), but their simple anime-ness, though self-aware, seems earnest. The acting is a bit stiff, and there are some rough spots in the pacing, but overall the flow is pretty good.

An impressive feat for a one-man studio, these shorts are fun enough to be worth watching as a diversion on their own, and good enough to be of particular interest to fans or potential creators of indie anime.

Read the full-length review...

Full Review

• Reviewer: Marc
• Review Date: 2003-06-08 (updated 2012-07-21)
• 2 stars out of 5 (?)

Since this perfect collection is made up of three individual shorts, I'll cover each briefly, but first some comments on the production in general: One common thread in White Radish's shorts is the way they capture the classic anime feel, boiling down a few simple plot elements and adding a little satirical twist. The stories are bare-bones (cute, scantily-clad girls fighting monsters and young boys battling evil), but their simple anime-ness, though self-aware, seems earnest, rather than feeling like a jaded parody or send-up.

These shorts' one other consistent (and consistently good) feature is their quality art; they have a traditional look (leaning toward chubby and cute), and though the production tools are digital (as with most modern professional Japanese animation), they are animated frame-by-frame from hand-drawn cels. The resulting product definitely has an anime feel to it--simple and rather fanservice-heavy, but still genuine. It's worth noting that of the various non-Japanese indie studios that have produced anime as of the mid-2000s, White Radish is the only one still in operation that uses cel-by-cel animation.

Now for some details on each individual production:

The Item

This is, depending on how you look at it, a distilled indie take on the "cute girls offering fanservice and action" class of anime, or a satire of it. I'll go with the middle ground, sort of a straightforward but slightly tongue-in-cheek presentation of all the required elements.

The timing in this piece is a little rough, showing a bit of an amateur air, but overall the action flows smoothly enough, and the various fight sequences came out well enough to be worthwhile. The chubby (not quite SD, but in that direction) character designs are certainly cute, and there's a very nicely done Sailor Moon-style transformation sequence. The voice cast is a tad stiff (some of the blame falling on the editing), but isn't all that bad.

The Apprentice

Of the three shorts, this is the longest, most serious, and the closest to a filled-out story (it also has no mature content, unlike the other two). The plot is a simple one--bad sorceress versus idealistic young apprentice--but it actually flows pretty well after a somewhat abrupt start.

There are a couple of nice demon-summoning scenes (the demon even sounds reasonably impressive), and a few minutes are spent developing the characters--the gleefully evil sorceress is certainly fun, mostly because of her expressive face. The centerpiece is probably the climactic action sequence; it doesn't have the most punchy timing but it came out pretty well, and features some nice-looking magical special effects.

In all, The Apprentice shows a significant improvement over the earlier The Item, and demonstrates what White Radish is capable of; the timing is still a bit stiff, but it combines a decent voice cast, decent animation, and a simple but complete story to make an all-around worthy little bite-sized chunk of anime.

The Evil At Tentacle High

The Evil At Tentacle High is about as long as its title--it's really just a visual joke, though it is a pretty good one. The chibi characters are cute, and despite the tentacle porn jab, it's not serious enough to be particularly offensive.

Cutethulu

This similar one-joke short replaces The Evil At Tentacle High on a later "Magic & Monsters" edition of the collection; it's also freely viewable online at Newsgrounds.

Cutethulu was produced several years after the other shorts, and it shows--the animation techniques have improved significantly, the art is clean and cute, and the timing is sharp. The voice acting for the handful of lines is perky and, frankly, better than a lot of older professional dubs. It's a nice-looking little gag, and I like the punchline, particularly if you're a Lovecraft fan.

Notably for those interested in production techniques, it's done in Flash, but that's clearly a tool, not a liability or limitation--the animation looks a lot more like modern cel work than "Flash animation." Even at only a minute and a half long, it's pretty impressive for the work of one guy.

Overall

Overall, as a collection, this is a nice package--some cheese at the beginning, something more solid in the middle, and a chuckle to finish up. None of the segments break any new ground, but in the end they're fun, which is worth plenty.

Have something to say about this anime? Join our newly-resurrected forums and speak your mind.

Related Recommendations

Obviously the first things that come to mind are the variety of other indie shorts, with II: Prologue from Pseudome being the most similar in terms of feel. Project A-ko and Debutante Detective Corps come to mind as other schoolgirl parodies, although I can't think of any fantasy stories with quite the same focused scope--most are more grandiose.